Sunday, April 22, 2007

New Approach to Diversity in Faculty Hires

Typically when we seek to hire diverse candidates, a hiring committee adds a name to the short list of someone who might be a minority. This new approach sounds like the best option, instead department should seek to hire any minority they deem of suitable quality, regardless of field. In this way departments might be able to increase the numbers of minority profs (which is important if the student pool is diverse) who have a better chance at tenure.

New Approach to Diversity

"Which is more important — that a department have all of its disciplinary subfields represented or that it diversify its faculty?...But as a small liberal arts university in a rural setting, Colgate has a hard time holding on to minority professors — and so needs to keep hiring them as well as trying to encourage more of them to make their careers at the university. Roelofs has asked departments to flop the second and third criteria. Excellence will stay on top, but diversity would generally trump subfield choice."

3 comments:

Anonymous said...

Professors should be hired on their knowledge and accomplishments, not what skin color or background they are.

Brandon Valeriano said...

Well, thats the point of that article. That we should seek to hire a minority candidate of suitable quality rather than make it an affirmative action decision.

Minority scholars are important. I just wrote a whole article about how the questions we ask are different and relevant. In addition, who are minority students supposed to look up to and get mentoring help from if there are no minority profs?

Trouper said...

I agree. Minority professors are necessary, especially in such a diverse campus as UIC. I would agree that they serve the function of a "mentor" to the minority students.

However, I also agree with Jenny in that their knowledge should come first. When people pay for an education, they want excellence, not diversity.

In my opinion, some of my best classes are those classes that are taught by international professors. They always have a different perspective that they can present. This really helps prepare us for the real world ... the diverse United States of America.

Andy Troup
POLS 184